| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | KURT WARNER | CARDINALS | Can still play as he showed all season and playoffs. | RE-SIGNED |
| 2 | MATT CASSELL | PATRIOTS | Traded to Chiefs along with Mike Vrabel. | FRANCHISED |
| 3 | KERRY COLLINS | TITANS | Had great season, should re-sign. | RE-SIGNED |
| 4 | JEFF GARCIA | BUCS | Had a decent season, no one knows who'll start in '09. | |
| 5 | JP LOSMAN | BILLS | Backed up Trent Edwards, could be a nice backup. | |
| 6 | KYLE BOLLER | RAVENS | Had an up and down career, Flacco won the job. | |
| 7 | CHRIS SIMMS | TITANS | Decent backup for the Broncos. | BRONCOS |
| 8 | BYRON LEFTWICH | STEELERS | Nice backup to BEN and Batch. | |
| 9 | DAN ORLOVSKY | LIONS | Should get lots of playing time in Houston. | TEXANS |
| 10 | DAVID CARR | GIANTS | Didn't play, but could be a good backup for any team. |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | BRANDON JACOBS | GIANTS | Should re-sign but might go after the money. | FRANCHISED |
| 2 | DARREN SPROLES | CHARGERS | Will look for a similar situation as Michael Turner. | FRANCHISED |
| 3 | DERRICK WARD | GIANTS | We'll see what he can do without Jacobs. | BUCS |
| 4 | FRED TAYLOR | JAGUARS | Good veteran pickup by the Patriots. | PATRIOTS |
| 5 | CEDRIC BENSON | BENGALS | Came on strong late in the year. | RE-SIGNED |
| 6 | CORRELL BUCKHALTER | EAGLES | Showed flashes in absence of Westbrook. | BRONCOS |
| 7 | MAURICE MORRIS | SEAHAWKS | Had a decent year. | LIONS |
| 8 | J.J. ARRINGTON | CARDINALS | Good value player w/ his added returning ability. | BRONCOS |
| 9 | RUDI JOHNSON | LIONS | Should retire, can't run anymore. | |
| 10 | LAMONT JORDAN | PATRIOTS | Didn't have the year he was expected to have. |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | T.J. HOUSHMANDZADEH | BENGALS | Top players available, should get huge money. | SEAHAWKS |
| 2 | ANTONIO BRYANT | BUCCANEERS | Had good year, could land anywhere. | FRANCHISED |
| 3 | LANCE MOORE | SAINTS | Stepped up in Colston's absence, good slot WR. | RE-SIGNED |
| 4 | MALCOM FLOYD | CHARGERS | Huge target for any QB, had awesome year. | |
| 5 | AMANI TOOMER | GIANTS | Age is the only question. | |
| 6 | BRYANT JOHNSON | 49ERS | Didn't have the year he expected. | LIONS |
| 7 | BOBBY ENGRAM | SEAHAWKS | Had a decent year. | |
| 8 | HANK BASKETT | EAGLES | Good receiver, dropped balls occasionally. | |
| 9 | DEVERY HENDERSON | SAINTS | Good hands and down field threat. | RE-SIGNED |
| 10 | NATE WASHINGTON | STEELERS | Had an ok year on a good receiving corps. | TITANS |
| 11 | DEMETRIUS WILLIAMS | RAVENS | Nice target, should get a good deal somewhere. | |
| 12 | JABAR GAFFNEY | PATRIOTS | Good compliment to Moss and Welker. | |
| 13 | BRANDON JONES | TITANS | Had his best season as a pro. | 49ERS |
| 14 | SHAUN MCDONALD | LIONS | Can't catch a pass if it's not in Martz system. | |
| 15 | JUSTIN MCCAREINS | TITANS | Had a decent year at best. | RE-SIGNED |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | OWEN DANIELS | TEXANS | Best TE available, he's RFA and should get lots of money. | |
| 2 | BO SCAIFE | TITANS | Will have lots of suitors as being the best UFA TE available. | FRANCHISED |
| 3 | L.J. SMITH | EAGLES | Good TE, had a good year. | |
| 4 | LEONARD POPE | CARDINALS | Was a good compliment on the pass happy system. | |
| 5 | JIM KLEINSASSER | VIKINGS | Age might have caught up with him. |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | JORDAN GROSS | PANTHERS | Franchise LT, should be franchise tagged immediately. | RE-SIGNED |
| 2 | STACY ANDREWS | BENGALS | Good tackle, Bengals must do whatever it takes to re-sign. | EAGLES |
| 3 | MARVEL SMITH | STEELERS | Big part of that Super Bowl run, should be back in Pitt. | |
| 4 | MARK TAUSCHER | PACKERS | Has had a good career, but Packers might let him go. | |
| 5 | KHALIF BARNES | JAGUARS | One of the few good young tackles available. | |
| 6 | JON RUNYAN | EAGLES | Great career, it's only matter of age. | |
| 7 | TRA THOMAS | EAGLES | Same as Runyan. | |
| 8 | WILLIE COLON | STEELERS | Had good year w/ Steelers. | |
| 9 | VERNON CAREY | DOLPHINS | Had a great year, will look to re-sign with Dolphins. | RE-SIGNED |
| 10 | MAX STARKS | STEELERS | Great T, same as Marvel Smith. | RE-SIGNED |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | JAHRI EVANS | SAINTS | Another young offensive linemen available, he's a RFA. | |
| 2 | MIKE GOFF | CHARGERS | Age might have caught up to him, but he can still play. | |
| 3 | PETE KENDALL | REDSKINS | Same as Goff. | |
| 4 | STEPHEN PETERMAN | LIONS | Stepped up late in year, should look to re-sign. | RE-SIGNED |
| 5 | MARK SETTERSTROM | RAMS | Good young Guard, had great year. |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | JASON BROWN | RAVENS | One of the youngest centers out there, should be back. | RAMS |
| 2 | JEFF SATURDAY | COLTS | Captain of that offense, next to Manning. | RE-SIGNED |
| 3 | MATT BIRK | VIKINGS | Veteran leader of that offense. | |
| 4 | BRAD MEESTER | JAGUARS | Good leader and player. | RE-SIGNED |
| 5 | RICHIE INCOGNITO | RAMS | Had a nice year, should look to return. |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | JULIUS PEPPERS | PANTHERS | Top DE/LB, wants to play in 3/4 and won't return. | FRANCHISED |
| 2 | TERRELL SUGGS | RAVENS | Right up there with Peppers, should get big contract. | FRANCHISED |
| 3 | ANTONIO SMITH | CARDINALS | Good DE, was a huge part of the Cardinals playoff run. | TEXANS |
| 4 | CHRIS CANTY | COWBOYS | Started all year long, was good throughout. | GIANTS |
| 5 | BERTRAND BERRY | CARDINALS | Same as Antonio Smith. | |
| 6 | KEVIN CARTER | BUCCANEERS | He's been decent lately, but has lost a couple steps. | |
| 7 | VICTOR ADEYANJU | RAMS | Had a good year and should be well sought after. | |
| 8 | EBENEZER EKUBAN | BRONCOS | Good young DE, hasn't hit his potential yet. | |
| 9 | EARL COCHRAN | TEXANS | Good decent end. | |
| 10 | DWAN EDWARDS | RAVENS | Stepped in and showed flashes. |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | ALBERT HAYNESWORTH | TITANS | Top player available, should get HUGE contract. | REDSKINS |
| 2 | ROCKY BERNARD | SEAHAWKS | Good DT, any team would love to add his frame. | GIANTS |
| 3 | JOVAN HAYE | BUCCANEERS | Good young D Linemen. | TITANS |
| 4 | KEDRIC GOLSTON | REDSKINS | Had a good year once again. | |
| 5 | SHAUN CODY | LIONS | Has been a bust since he stepped on the field. |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | RAY LEWIS | RAVENS | His presence gives any defense more respect. | RE-SIGNED |
| 2 | JONATHAN VILMA | SAINTS | Had a good year w/ Saints, should re-sign. | RE-SIGNED |
| 3 | KARLOS DANSBY | CARDINALS | Had a great year, Cards should not let him go. | FRANCHISED |
| 4 | CHANNING CROWDER | DOLPHINS | Good young LB, might be franchised. | RE-SIGNED |
| 5 | BART SCOTT | RAVENS | Good LB, always around the ball and should re-sign. | JETS |
| 6 | MICHAEL BOLEY | FALCONS | Great young LB, fast on his feet and pursuit to ball. | GIANTS |
| 7 | LEROY HILL | SEAHAWKS | Good young LB. Had a good year on a bad team. | FRANCHISED |
| 8 | RASHAD JEANTY | BENGALS | Had a decent year on a horrible team. | |
| 9 | ANGELO CROWELL | BILLS | Good young LB, should start anywhere he goes. | |
| 10 | MARQUES HARRIS | CHARGERS | Stepped in for injuries and had a good year. | |
| 11 | ANDRA DAVIS | BROWNS | Another young LB who had a good year. | BRONCOS |
| 12 | MIKE PETERSON | JAGUARS | Veteran leader, should boost any defense. | |
| 13 | ERIC BARTON | JETS | Good tackler and had a good year. | |
| 14 | NATE WEBSTER | BRONCOS | Good player who will most likely go elsewhere. | |
| 15 | CLARK HAGGANS | CARDINALS | Had a good year mostly as backup. |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | NNAMDI ASOMUGHA | RAIDERS | Top d back out there, will go after the money. | RE-SIGNED |
| 2 | DUNTA ROBINSON | TEXANS | Great young corner. | FRANCHISED |
| 3 | JABARI GREER | BILLS | Any team would love to add him. | SAINTS |
| 4 | DOMONIQUE FOXWORTH | FALCONS | Had a good year, Falcons should retain him. | BRONCOS |
| 5 | PHILIP BUCHANON | BUCCANEERS | Good all around corner. | LIONS |
| 6 | ADAM "PACMAN" JONES | COWBOYS | Trouble, don't expect for him to play in '09. | |
| 7 | LEIGH BODDEN | LIONS | Good player on a bad team. | |
| 8 | BRYANT MCFADDEN | STEELERS | Had a great season on that Super defense. | |
| 9 | RICKY MANNING JR. | RAMS | Stepped up at times, should re-sign. | |
| 10 | DEMARCUS FAGGINS | TEXANS | Had a decent year. | |
| 11 | JUSTIN MILLER | RAIDERS | Good value player with kick return abilities. | |
| 12 | ANDRE GOODMAN | DOLPHINS | Was up and down. | BRONCOS |
| 13 | DELTHA O'NEAL | PATRIOTS | Stepped in for Samuel's and had a decent year. | |
| 14 | ERIC GREEN | CARDINALS | Good nickel back. | |
| 15 | KEVIN DOCKERY | GIANTS | Filled in nicely for those young corners. |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | JERMAINE PHILLIPS | BUCCANEERS | Top safety available, should get a big deal. | RE-SIGNED |
| 2 | OSHIOMOGHO ATOGWE | RAMS | Had an huge year, good knack for the ball. | |
| 3 | SEAN JONES | BROWNS | Good young safety, Browns need him back. | |
| 4 | RODNEY HARRISON | PATRIOTS | Might retire. | |
| 5 | MIKE BROWN | BEARS | Great leader and should be back. | |
| 6 | DARREN SHARPER | VIKINGS | Has lost a step each of the past couple years. | |
| 7 | LAWYER MILLOY | FALCONS | Falcons need a safety, Milloy might not be back. | |
| 8 | DAWAN LANDRY | RAVENS | Good young safety, should be sought after a lot. | |
| 9 | YEREMIAH BELL | DOLPHINS | Had a good year. | RE-SIGNED |
| 10 | RENALDO HILL | DOLPHINS | Same as Bell. |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | ROB BIRONAS | TITANS | One of the most clutch kickers in the game today. | RE-SIGNED |
| 2 | SHAYNE GRAHAM | BENGALS | One of the few bright spots on the Bengals team. | FRANCHISED |
| 3 | MIKE NUGENT | JETS | Jets used 2nd round pick on him, is their franchise K. | BUCS |
| 4 | JASON HANSON | LIONS | Next to Calvin Johnson, was the offensive MVP of the team. | RE-SIGNED |
| 5 | SHAUN SUISHAM | REDSKINS | Good young K, should be back. |
| RANK | NAME | TEAM | COMMENTS | NEW TEAM |
| 1 | MICHAEL KOENEN | FALCONS | Great young punter. | FRANCHISED |
| 2 | SHANE LECHLER | RAIDERS | One of the bright spots on that Raiders team. | RE-SIGNED |
| 3 | CRAIG HENTRICH | TITANS | Might retire, but can still kick. | RE-SIGNED |
| 4 | SAM KOCH | RAVENS | One of many Ravens FAs. | |
| 5 | HUNTER SMITH | COLTS | Good punter, has a great leg. |